The Art of Visual Semantics

Sometimes you have to laugh at yourself.. Hahaha.!!

Cause all this time I have assured myself that when it comes to cover-art, our creative story-telling genius is as clear as day for all the world to see; communicating the timeless message of Christ in such grandeur clarity and relevance that it’s impossible not to find redemption simply by looking at the front cover of our albums; graphical design so deep and complex that it speaks eternal truths to the soul through the iris’s of all who are privileged enough to set eyes upon such visual masterpieces. HA! Think about it; 2004; “MORE THAN LIFE” - a clip-art-extravaganza which involved hundreds of meticulous hours spent cutting out images of people in our youth ministry and zoo animals and other random objects that represented all that life entailed to us at the time.. And above it all we blasted the word “UNITED’ and had some random images of musicians worshipping our God, so as if to visually declare “ohhh I looove yoouu.. Moooooore than liiiiiife”. 

I mean for real.. It was brilliant!! And yet, in response, all we got was a hundred angry emails about how in amongst the plethora of layered images there was a particular image of MGC making a symbol that apparently represented the devil!!!

Now while I can see how that conclusion has been derived, and it was probably a blight on our behalf to leave it in there knowing the vast chasm that exists in regard to what is culturally acceptable around the world, i was still taken aback, cause honestly; are we really that religious?? i mean,  is the devil even worthy of that measure of credence?? I don’t know.. I reckon the devil is a tool, and not worth the effort it takes to make a 2 fingered salute.. (perhaps a single digit salute is more suffice.. Haha)! but still, some people were unhappy, and so we apologized to all whom we offended, and did our best to clarify that in the context of our culture the symbol in question simply refers to the idea of ‘rock and roll’ - and less the 80’s inspired back-masking-subliminal-evil-messages-snake-head-biting kinda rock and roll.. But more the hug-your-mate-shrug-off-the-shackles-of-scrupulous-religious-nitpicking kinda rock and roll.. i know i may have just offended more people, but pleaase.. hear my heart. bigger fish to fry I reckon...

Then there was 2005; "LOOK TO YOU’ - got to deadline day and realized the artwork was less than satisfactory. Came up with the bright idea to paint the artwork on a blank wall in the community youth service; time lapse it; tell a story within the booklet pointing toward what it means to ‘look to God’ in the midst of all the distractions of a world consumed with itself. At the time spray paint was all the rage. So in an 11th hour contingency effort we raided the local hardware store; printed live images on gridded A3 sheets; stocked up on red bulls and krispy kreme’s and painted the night away, and as the sun began to creep over the horizon we sat back and marveled at our ‘mona lisa’. It was beautiful. Less for the quality of artwork, and more for the experience. But did anyone really notice.? I just remember getting jibes about the fact that it was called ‘look to you’ yet everyone was looking down?? Eyes to the sky people. apparently that's where God is..?

the year 2006; UNITED WE STAND was a shift away from torn paper layers, spray paint and handwritten blah-blahs towards  a clean, photo-based approach. But not the classic picture of the passionate worship leader appropriately poised mid praise-move (made famous in the 1990’s and unfortunately continued all too often 20 years later). No this was about capturing the heart of OUR PEOPLE. Not just the few involved in playing an instrument or singing the song way up on that wonderful platform we so crave called the stage. No, it was about positioning the minor-christian-pseudo-celebrities such as my tall-lanky-self where we belong; in and behind the real heroes; the crew who are doin it week in, week out, unseen, unsung. it was a response to struggling with the contradictory nature of being a 'church-based-worship-band' passionate about pointing people toward God and dealing a little too often with the awkward nature of photographs and autographs and fan-mail and realizing that some people are perhaps focusing a lil' too much on us. So reactively we positioned ourselves in and amongst and behind our crew at large. All of us together, united, making a stand. Even made it so the cover was black, making it hard for the conventional sharpie to make it’s mark. All was going to plan till we found ourselves at a christian book store in orange county doing a CD signing with, wait for it... silver sharpies!!! huh? Didn’t everyone get it? Did anyone get it? Did our management even get it? Did we get it?? Of course i'll smile awkwardly for a photo, or sign a CD or t-shirt or shoe if asked at the appropriate time - kinda rude not to, but still i wonder if anyone, anywhere got the symbolic message wrapped up within the artwork. I don't know if even we did.  Brooke put it best while recently being bombarded mid-worship set with budding photographers.. "we're not golden calves people.." I had to laugh.. heavy.. but frighteningly appropriate none-the-less. 

so given this was a perpetuating issue we continued the theme with ALL OF THE ABOVE; a simple little play on words, taking a leaf from feedback gleaned from 'look to you' assuming that God is only up above us (as opposed to the idea He is perhaps everywhere, being omnipresent and all?), and given that we're all about all that He is about, we thought it novel to capture once again our crew-at-large adorning t-shirts blasted with sharpie, and this time not signatures, but rather core-value-statement-words; FAITH, HOPE, LOVE, TRUTH, PEACE, OTHERS ETC....  so much as to say that these are the things that we're about. inside we had pics and statements of some of our crew, one of which caused particular controversy because he was revealing his ink; praying hands across his left pectoral. again there were letters questioning whether we were truly following Christ if we were endorsing such a thing..... hmm... don't get me started.. either way, seems the point was lost... or was it.?? i really don't know.. perhaps all along we're making a point.? But is anyone getting it...?

after 2008 spawned the first installment of the i-heart journey;"WITH HEARTS AS ONE", once again the letters flooded in. This time regarding our use of the 'Christ the redeemer' statue in rio de janeiro; a statue that for many (in brazil most notably) represents idolatry and even forms of paganism, which is intriguing given the magnificent statement the statue makes to a visitor such as myself. the "i-heart" made out of images wasn't supposed to represent our christian worldview of the world as much as it was simply supposed to portray the diversity of the world in full.  But having read into it, i do have to agree that Jesus didn't come to earth and die a criminal's death upon a cross meant for us, and rise again so that we would view Him 2000 odd years later as a statue.. but like anything, you choose to make of things what you wanna make of things.. the point is; are we lost in our visual semantics, or is it possible there's a point to all of this??

cause it's 2009 and finally i'm holding a finished, printed, real-life copy of our new project, dual title and all; a CROSS // the EARTH : TEAR DOWN THE WALLS.  it has no cover.

and already we’re receiving the letters. "i didn't receive the booklet", "did the recession bite your production budget?", "how am i supposed to open it?" etc....

and i have to laugh.. cause in my mind i thought it was obvious.. i thought it was genius.. no cover... a wall adorned with bill posters representing the EARTH... four triangles (representing worship nights) revealing a CROSS.. all of which revealed without a cover; representing transparency; the walls removed; nothing to hide; just as we are; but by the grace of God etc.. and for added effect we'd wrap it in a paper sticker that you literally have to 'tear' to get into the album... But obviously not so obvious.. And apparently less than being anything close to genius.. cause here i am spelling it out for everyone... i definitely underestimated the significance of a booklet... and here is my promise, next album.. we're goin all out with the booklet.. (recycled paper of course).. It’ll be how people choose to define ‘booklet’ in years to come.. taking it back to the 'ENDS OF THE EARTH' days, where we literally cut our teeth with no idea of what we were doing, experimenting the limits of photoshop, and spending weeks on end trying to make the booklet work (we spent four day working out how to crop..), whatever it took to redeem UNITED and it's tagline "radical worship" from KING OF MAJESTY.. hahaha..

So our disclaimer (aka pride-mechanism) is that this was before we had any creative control.. In fact it was in dissatisfied response to this that we got involved in the art in the first place.. But have we done any better.?? Or are we kidding ourselves? I reckon it's arguable at best.. And only time will really tell.. one thing is for sure; everything dates, and what we think is cool or rad or dope or whatever is more than likely – not.. and at the end of the day, our art is simply a donkey.. Just like the one that carried Jesus.. just a donkey, who’s purpose was to carry the Savior.. The same goes for all our creative expression; our music; our photography; our design; our talents and gifts etc.  whatever it is, our challenge above all else is to make sure it carries HIM. That it serves to carry the life giving message of Christ.  We get that right, and it'll do the job..

if you got this far, thanks for reading.
Love.
Jth.

And if you have further complaints, please send them to: iprobablywontreadthem@betterthingstodo.com

Comments

I was intrigued by the new album cover. So I pondered what the message was. I assumed that having to tear the sticker had a relation to the title. Also, I wondered about there being no booklet, as I like to know the lyrics. However, I have had to REALLY listen to to the lyrics, and I think it allowed me to have a deeper understanding of the songs. This being said, I think this is a fantastic album. When I first listened to it, I got the feeling of something awesome. I got tingles the first time I listened to Tear Down the Walls. Thank you so much for the album!

i'll admit, in my haste i demanded a booklet.
but now... i don't want one.

i want to marvel at the symbolism.

lol-Thanks! It was excellent class(haha..JK!).

well, surprising. I've never thought that artworks are also from you+hilllsong united's singers and players. Amazing! Can't wait to see another one releases in Oct.

Anyway, 'tear down on the walls' the new album, it's brilliant. Really. I just bought CD's and already had played 3 times. (memorized some songs too) Really great. And congratulations that album is on #2 in iTunes. So proud of it and praise GOD(I believe even non-christian will hear that and accept GOD as their saviour because of that situation)!!

+really want to buy the last one-king of majesty-but so hard to find that in Korea....:-| I'm keep looking it.

hi, nice cd you guys have! but i was wondering, when are you coming on a tour to Europe? i'dd love to see you guys live (and ki/ro-cking;)) so please somewhere near Belgium, like the Netherlands, or Germany, or even better in belgium itself!

grts a big fan of yours (and her friend that's even a bigger fan of yours)

gods bless!

Sarah and Grace

+one more. Thanks for the explanation. Yes, I had to 'tear' it but you have to remember this. After that 'tearing' I had to wash it the back and sides w/ lots of things.(Cuz after I tore that, the band put on the back was just refused to be re-posted) So I used lotion, acetone and.....even my nails. Whew.

Just want to let you know. Haha
-But I think that thought is just genious.

Anyway thanks again!

Well i absolutely loved the cover (or lack there-of), and also the music. Although sometimes i could use the lyrics (Australian accents can be hard to understand sometimes) you guys are doing a fantastic job! I truly cannot wait to experience what God has for me during ENCOUNTER in Anaheim. See you there!

I think the artwork is awesome and actually never noticed the critiqued things. Oops? I'm a designer and show it to my friends who aren't saved and love design and they love it. Particularly the i heart.Sad that you only get critics not encouragers. Keep it going! It's great!

HAHA this is great, i admire of how much thought goes into the album art, and i think people have alittle too much time to sit and examine an album cover,

oh and your comparison to our art and an donkey is great, blew my mind, love the blogs guys especially this one....

SICK ALBUM-TEAR DOWN THE WALLS
KEEP THE GREAT JOB UP!!!
LOVE FRM MELBOURNE

After reading though all of this long post, the least i could do really is leave a simple reply (which im not really a fan of, especially on the internet). I have never really been very interested in album arts (i suppose that's because im not a design/graphical art aficionado) but this is still an insightful piece nonetheless. Extra info never did anyone any harm right ?. I gotta admit though, i had intermittent chuckles (at the way you addressed the album art 'moaners') as i was reading through this post. Ofcourse you didnt say it in such simple terms, but by the diction and verbiage of this post, thats one word i can deduce you probably had in your mind; and im not claivoryant or anything. Quite astonishing that people who go as far as sending you guys complaint mails/letters regarding album arts. It's one thing to have an opinion about such but to go such extreme lengths is just startling.

Guess what, Ill now start paying attention to the UNITED album arts...hehe

Thanks for the good read and i hope you guys have a great and blessed tour

Adam (Johannesburg, SA)

HAHA! That's fantastic. Creatively genius. I never took too much consideration of the art other than, its beautiful - lets preserve it. cos reality is, the heart of worship really counts!

tear down the walls .. was pretty hard to for one to get your message, jth. I for one used a knife to neatly open the cd so that there wouldnt be any tear marks. kinda defeats the purpose huh..? hehe. instead of a cross i saw a butterfly :)

god bless.
enjoy the tour // you are the church.

Hahahaha!!! It was funny all the way!!
I was shocked when i read people sending letters about random, useless things on the cover??? Anyway...I live in South Africa and we'll only get the new CD tomorrow - i hope - and i think it's a brilliant idea for the cover. What really does matter though is what's on the disc. I know people who don't even keep the cover, only the disc. And above all let Jesus' name be lifted higher through all we do and to find the devil in everything is only what he wants us to do in the first place. He does not give a damn about you...only himself. With or without a tattoo, with or without looking up or down to God, with or without the statue in Rio...the devil hates yo guts. Becuase he knows that Jesus already won the day He was crucified and we have eternal life. Not even the devil will take that away...and so we have to pray that eyes will be opened to what matters!! Covers are cool, but they don't rule the whole point of a cd...UNITED through their music is touching more lives than most of us can imagine. And the devil wants to bring division among us. They worship God and adore Him. And at the end of the day they have to stand in front of God and give account of what they did with their lives. Each of us have to. Just let God be God and let Him take care of the big stuff, all He wants is our hearts and our worship. Our lives...

I like it when you said: 'if you got this far, thanks for reading.' :D

just want to say where you metioned about:
'the 'Christ the redeemer' statue in rio de janeiro'...on the ablum cover.
As nation like us, full of idolatry and forms of paganism(the Daoism),
us, especailly the 1st generation born again christian , we always are oppressed by the false spirit like thoes.
we fight,so to us, a statue or an image is real serious.

this is not a complaint,we believe in hillsong united,
to me it was not a matter,but sometimes where it comes to unbelievers,
we need to tell them what is different between our Belief and other false one.

surely you will know what I mean:)

keep going~~xoxo

The statue is a problem when you worship it....
depends of the eyes that see it... When I saw the Christ Redeemer, I had the feeling of peace and how Majesty God is; but I know that people can feel or think different things when they look at it.

I know what you mean, but we need to breakthrough a lot of things in Brazil, like this one...
There is more stuff that we should be worried about.

Ps: I know that we need to fight against idolatry and a lot of forms of paganism that Brazil has... it's huge in Brazil; but we need to change some of our christians mindset as well... but surly we need to show to the world that our God reigns...

i hope that you can understand what I'm trying to say
I'm not in favor of idolatry!! (just make this clear!)
God bless

I have thoroughly enjoyed reading this and really agree with what you say. So many people these days focus on the negatives and not the fantastic things that the community of God are doing. I am only 15 and feel that these albums and the countless others around the world from such talented people are such a blessing; they spread the word of God everyhwhere and make an impact on the world which is what Jesus has done. I sing in my worship band and love singing for God. As you say sometimes people focus too much on us and not God. He is what it's all about. No one else. The art on the covers is fantastic and the small things that people pick out really don't matter, it's pathetic that people dwell on this and they forget the bigger picture that is the most important thing. Sometimes we get so caught up in the small things and perfecting every little thing that we don't enjoy ourselves anymore and I just thank you guys for not doing so. Thanks for keeping things real and not being afraid to say what you think. Please keep up the amazing ministry you guys have. =]

Hi Joel
I think people have the desire to criticize and this CD and all CD Hillsong has served for more people to know God.
I'm in Spain waiting for the CD with plenty of enthusiasm!
Sorry for my English
Blessings to you and all of Hillsong
Betsy

referring to your last part your blog ......

... --> ...whatever it is, our challenge above all else is to make sure it carries HIM. That it serves to carry the life giving message of Christ. We get that right, and it'll do the job....

amen =)

...hey brother , its all about Him, Jesus...His glory....=)

Shalom...=)

can't wait to have it! it's always too long time for me till it arrives to Hungary... but surely i won't miss this!

The covers of these albums are fantastic!! they all show a unique but similar message. like, im 15 and doing cd covers for my youth and they are apparently fantastic haha.....but it comes back to the fact that the bible tells us to do all things for our God. so we need to do it 4 Him.!! anyway i think they are fantastic, the new album is truly AMAZING and cant wait 4 the next installment.! and the album cover!!!!! YEWWW

Benjamin

AWESOME!

Praise God for the work of UNITED.

Nath

this post cracked me up. i actually have never thought about the message behind the covers i only care about the music so i would say that your purpose to make Jesus known and glorified is fulfilled in my life regardless of the cover. but it was still fun to read how the covers are made and the strange responses you've had from people.

It's great that you redirect the focus toward God. It's all about Him and less of us. That shows a true heart of worship, real humility, passion for souls and love of Christ. Praise be to Jesus! May we further His Kingdom!

Hmm.. ?? I think it is a genius idea.. I get the no cover means no wall, I get the sticker that needs to be torn represent the action of 'tear down'.. as a start, the simple action, tearing the sticker...Hey.. can not please ALL people, can we? What is matter, is the motivation behind it, isn't it..? But, yea.. I need the booklet cover for me to learn the lyrics.. :)

No complaints here! It is amazing how hard you all work at this , and how in the midst of it all you get criticism.

Do people understand this simple truth: We all view things differently!

If we didn't think and love in different ways we would not be independent. If we didn't have that independence then God could have just made use to worship Him. But He wanted us to want it. He wanted us to seek him, not to do it out of a forced relationship.

I for one am glad some don't like it, i know there are churches and communities that would trouble me. But I still love them and I hope the critics will think about that the next time they leave feedback.

Thanks again for all you do. I hope you are encouraged that God is being glorified, even when you feel like a golden calf.

Last night in Atlanta was an awesome time in the LORD!! GOD showed up in a big way; showing His majesty by opening up the heavens and participating with us in person.GOD rained down His love and His Spirit upon us.

I have followed Hillsong for over 15 years. First time was in Chicago at Willow Creek and from then, every album ever produced I own. I will continue to pray for each one of you. I will tell others about the message. I will tell others of God's Great Love for them.

Be Blessed
MLS

i particularly love this post.
just because of the explanation on the cover arts.
it has inspired me all the time as much as i like all the songs.
i didn't even notice the lil socalled errors. haha

especially ... the last album, i was kinda puzzle that i didn't get the booklet and i know that, theres something meaningful to it until i read your post.

keep the good work team.
Cheers
Thomas

Cover art, like anything else in life, is subject to the predispositions of the observer. You nailed it when you said that people will see what they wanna' see.

That being said, thanks for the explanations. I don't necessarily think that the covers have been "obvious" to the masses. For me, knowing the thought that went into them adds to their value.

But then, I wanted to like them before I read this. :-)

Peace,

-Michael

PS - heaven and earth definitely overlapped in Alpharetta last night... thanks for worshipping with us!

Well said. Thanks for always sharing your heart and helping point the world to the Savior!

hi joel,
hey im from South Africa, love you guys and what you do, amazing....just thought id let you know that i love you guys and the way you help me connect with God, its because of UNITED that iv gotten closer, so regardless of your cd covers (which by the way i think is genius, you guys are talented), people tend to overanalyse things and miss the bigger picture!!!

So hats off to you and the team that pull off the long hours to bring Gods message to the world! cant wait to hear the new album.

love you guys and everything you do,
God bless,
Shena,
p.s last year the concert was AWESOME, God was moving, look forward to seeing you guys again!!!

yes many comments... could be as long as yours but.. maybe later on in the night i will comment.. find someone to email. its harder when its your creation.. your baby and others suddenly take it completely in the wrong way or direction it was intended.. or don't even get it at all. i realize i sometimes find my identity in my creation and/or what people think of it. photo after photo after JPG after jpg.. webpage after homepage.. after url link and redirection and ARGH!?
why are we still doing this?!
creation.. He's put it in all of us.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.